Humanity · The Attack That Looks Manageable

For anyone with asthma, or living with someone who has it · 12 minutes

“My blue inhaler works” is not reassurance. It is the single most reliable warning sign that somebody is heading for the attack that kills them.

Asthma still kills people every week in Europe, and national reviews of those deaths keep finding the same short list: too much reliever inhaler, too little preventer, no written action plan, no review after the last attack, and a person who seemed to be coping right up until the hour they were not. Almost none of it is exotic medicine. It is a pattern that is visible weeks in advance, in four questions anybody can answer at a kitchen table, and it is treatable when somebody notices. This page is about noticing — and about the twenty minutes in an attack where knowing the routine changes the outcome.

reliever use more than twice a week means control has slipped
10 puffsthe emergency routine, one at a time, through a spacer
48 hoursthe window for a review after any attack, and it is usually missed
The reliever inhaler treats the symptom and does nothing to the inflammation underneath. Using it more often is not managing asthma better; it is measuring how fast the asthma is getting worse.

The four questions, and the sentence to take with you

These are the questions an asthma review asks, and most people have never been asked them in a row. Answer honestly — nothing is stored — and the tool assembles a sentence you can read out or hand over at an appointment. That sentence is the useful output, not the score.

Nothing is saved and nothing is sent anywhere. This is not a diagnosis or a substitute for a review: it is a way of turning a vague “my asthma is fine” into specifics a clinician can act on.

Two inhalers doing opposite jobs

Most asthma harm comes from a single misunderstanding: that the inhaler which makes you feel better is the one treating the disease. It is not. Colours vary by country and brand, so the words on the box matter more than the colour.

The reliever — often blue, taken when you are wheezy

It relaxes the muscle around the airway within minutes and wears off within hours. It does nothing to the swelling and mucus underneath, which is what actually narrows the airway and what kills people. It is a fire extinguisher, not a smoke alarm and not a repair.

The preventer — often brown, orange or purple, taken every day

An inhaled steroid, usually with a second medicine, that slowly reduces the inflammation. It does nothing you can feel today, which is exactly why people stop taking it — and why stopping it is the commonest step on the road to an admission. Taken daily it is the medicine that keeps you out of hospital.

What an attack actually looks like

The picture people expect is dramatic wheezing. The dangerous picture is quieter than that, and the quietest version is the worst one.

The emergency routine, for an attack that is not settling: sit them upright — never lie flat — and give one puff of the reliever through a spacer every 30 to 60 seconds, up to ten puffs, taking a few normal breaths from the spacer after each puff. Call the emergency number if there is no improvement after ten puffs, if the reliever is not lasting, if they cannot speak in sentences, or if you are frightened. While waiting, repeat the ten puffs after ten minutes. Do not leave the person alone, do not send them to walk or drive themselves anywhere, and do not wait to see whether it settles — a person can deteriorate in the time it takes to reconsider. In an emergency, 112.

The written action plan

A personal written plan roughly halves the risk of an admission, takes ten minutes to fill in with a clinician, and most people with asthma do not have one. It is the single highest-yield thing to ask for.

How to get one without a fight. Ask for an asthma review by name, say you would like a written action plan, and bring the sentence the tool above wrote for you. Reviews are routine, often nurse-led, usually free at the point of care, and they end with the plan, an inhaler-technique check and a prescription that matches how you actually live.

Why the medicine “does not work”

Study after study finds that most people use their inhaler wrongly, which means the dose ends up in the mouth and throat instead of the lungs. This is the cheapest fix in the entire subject and it is almost never checked.

  1. Use a spacer with a metered-dose inhaler, the kind you press. It roughly doubles what reaches the lungs, removes the need for perfect timing, and is not just for children — adults having an attack should be using one too.
  2. Shake, one puff at a time, slow and steady breath — not a hard fast suck. With a spacer, breathe normally from it four or five times after each puff. With a dry-powder inhaler the opposite applies: a quick, deep, forceful breath.
  3. Never fire several puffs into a spacer at once. The doses stick to the plastic and to each other; one puff, breathe, then the next.
  4. Rinse your mouth after a steroid inhaler to avoid thrush and a hoarse voice, which are among the reasons people quietly stop taking it.
  5. Check the counter, and check it is not empty. Shaking and floating in water tell you nothing. An inhaler that fires when it is empty is a common reason an attack “did not respond”.
  6. Wash the spacer monthly in warm soapy water and let it air-dry — do not rub it dry, because static reduces the dose that gets through.
When the inhalers genuinely do not help. Breathlessness has other causes that get labelled asthma for years: breathing-pattern disorders, vocal cord dysfunction, reflux, deconditioning, anxiety, heart failure, anaemia. If treatment is optimal, technique is confirmed, adherence is real and the tests are normal, asking “is this actually asthma?” is a legitimate question with treatable answers — breathing physiotherapy in particular. That conversation belongs at a review, though. During an attack, nobody diagnoses anxiety instead of asthma: treat it as asthma and get help.
Ask somebody to watch you use it. A pharmacist or nurse will do this free, in two minutes, and it is the most common single explanation for asthma that seems resistant to treatment. Bring your own devices, all of them, including the one you use rarely.

Steroid tablets, and the week after an attack

Triggers, ranked by how often they actually matter

The big ones

  • Respiratory infections — the commonest cause of attacks in both children and adults
  • Tobacco smoke, including smoke on clothes and in cars, and vaping around a child
  • Cold, dry air, and sudden weather changes
  • House-dust mite, damp and mould — which links this page to any cold, damp home
  • Pollen and thunderstorms in season; air pollution and traffic fumes
  • Exercise, which is a reason to treat the asthma properly rather than to stop exercising

Easy to miss

  • Anti-inflammatory painkillers — ibuprofen, aspirin, diclofenac — which trigger attacks in a subset of people
  • Beta-blocker tablets and some eye drops, worth naming at a medication review
  • Reflux, which worsens night-time symptoms
  • Strong smells, aerosols, cleaning sprays, scented candles
  • Stress and laughter, both of which are real triggers and neither of which is imaginary
  • Pets, where the honest question is what is actually possible for the household
The trigger nobody asks about: work. If symptoms are worse on working days and better on holidays or after a few days off, that pattern is occupational asthma — and it is common in bakers and food workers, cleaners, hairdressers, spray painters, welders, woodworkers, healthcare staff and anyone working with flour, isocyanates, solvents, animals or enzymes. It matters more than an ordinary trigger for one reason: caught early and the exposure removed, it can improve or resolve, and left for years it usually becomes permanent. Say the words “better away from work” to a doctor, keep a two-week diary of symptoms against shifts, and ask about occupational health — not about giving up the job as a first step.
Two seasonal things worth doing. Take the flu vaccination and any other vaccination you are offered — respiratory infection is the trigger most likely to put somebody in hospital. And if cold air sets you off, breathing through a loose scarf on the way to work is unglamorous and works.

Children, school and the things parents are told wrongly

Pregnancy, and the risk people get backwards

If you are with somebody having an attack

“Sit up straight for me — don't lie down.
Where is your reliever and your spacer? I'll get it.
One puff, then breathe normally four times. Again. I'm counting to ten.
Can you say a whole sentence for me?
You're not improving, so I'm calling now. Stay sitting, I'm right here.”

The drill: 16 decisions

Sixteen ordinary moments — a fourth canister this year, a night cough, a school trip, a chest that has gone quiet. Most have an instinctive answer that has killed people. Pick your move; every answer explains why.

The card

Print it for the fridge, the school bag and the wallet.

ASTHMA — THE ATTACK ROUTINE AND THE WARNING SIGNS

IN AN ATTACK

  • Sit upright. Never lie flat. Stay with them
  • One puff of reliever through a spacer every 30–60 seconds, up to 10 puffs, breathing normally between
  • No better after 10 puffs, reliever not lasting, or cannot speak a sentence: call 112
  • While waiting: repeat 10 puffs after 10 minutes
  • Silent chest, drowsy, blue lips, exhausted = worst, not better

THE FOUR QUESTIONS — ANY YES MEANS BOOK A REVIEW

  • Reliever more than twice a week?
  • Woken at night by asthma?
  • Asthma limiting anything you do?
  • More than two reliever canisters this year?

ALWAYS

  • Take the preventer every day, even when well. Rinse your mouth
  • Use a spacer; one puff at a time; get your technique watched
  • Finish every course of steroid tablets. Book a review after any attack
  • Written action plan — phone, fridge, school
My reliever: ____________ My preventer: ____________ Emergency contact: ____________ Emergency: 112.